This Meat & Cheese Shop in Shipshewana is So Worth Stopping For

Post Date: Oct 09, 2017

One of the best things about Shipshewana is the variety of wholesome food available. If you're looking for quality and local food, you've got to stop at this store. You're going to want to pack along a cooler. Trust me. 

Yoder's Meat & Cheese is an incredible store offering 150 cuts of meat, over 80 varieties of cheese, a full line of in-house smoked meats, a deli, jams and jellies, candy, salsas, popcorn, canned goods and much more.

It's actually located right on SR 5, right next to the Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market, which makes it a super convenient stop for shoppers, and for me! 

Walk into the store, and right away you'll notice the crowds around the coolers all with toothpicks in their hands.

Why? Because there are samples!

That's right, you can sample a few of the varieties of amazing meats and cheeses. I suggest trying each of them before you choose what flavor to purchase. You never know...you may end up loving the habanero cheese. I sure did!

Speaking of cheese, I highly suggest trying their in-house smoked varieties. My personal favorite is the smoked provolone. I just love the smokey flavor! According to Yoder Meat & Cheese's website, other customer favorites in the cheese section include the Amish Butter Cheese, Roasted Garlic, Vintage Habanero, Horseradish, Smoked Gouda, New York Sharp Cheddar and Lacey Baby Swiss. It may take you a lifetime just to try them all!

The cheese products are manufactured largely by different cheese-making operations in the Amish Mennonite communities of Indiana and Ohio.

And what about the meat? Well, you can bet the meat at Yoder's is top quality. They offer all-natural beef, pork, lamb and chicken.

They even have a grain-fed, grass-fed and GMO-free program. The beef are raised locally, then processed, packaged, and retailed at one location. Yoder's Meat & Cheese Company is a full USDA inspected company, maintaining the highest standard of food sanitation and safety operations.

And how about those in-house smoked meats? They use all natural hickory and cherry wood chips to get the best flavor for bacon, ring bologna, summer sausage, jerky, beef sticks, sausage, bratwurst, salami, smokey links and more. Is your mouth watering yet? 

If that isn't enough to get you to check the store out, maybe the artisan food section will catch your fancy! I could spend an hour just looking at the many varieties of salsa, jams, snacks and candy Yoder's Meat & Cheese has to offer. 

I also appreciate how they make sure every product in their store is quality or local. For example, the noodles come from a local Amish family, and the jams and jellies are made by Amish Mennonite families in the traditional home-style manner. 

Last summer, I decided to host a "chips and salsa tasting party" at my house. Where did I go to stock up on salsas? Yoder's Meat & Cheese! It was a hit! My friends and I loved tasting all the varieties like Pineapple, Peach, Habanero, and the classic Garden Salsa. 

Make sure Yoder's Meat & Cheese store is on your must-do list when visiting Shipshewana. I just know you'll drive away with a trunk full of delicious quality, wholesome goodness!

Want more trip ideas for visiting Shipshewana? Get the free download of the Shipshewana Trip Planner Guide.

Download Flea Market Trip Planner

Upcoming Events

Shipshewana Trading Place is home to the Midwest's Largest Flea Market, Weekly Auctions, an Amish-inspired Inn, and year-round events in Indiana's Amish Country. Check out what's going on by browsing our upcoming events.

Exclusive News & Deals

Be the first to be "in-the-know" on the latest news and special events taking place at Shipshewana Trading Place by signing up for our eNews.

Join Now

Vendor Selling Opportunities

Learn more about all of the great vendor opportunities at the Midwest's largest flea market and auction!

Learn More