16 Shipshewana Stocking Stuffer Stops

Post Date: Oct 28, 2022

Discover 16 shops in Shipshewana, IN that will delight your Christmas Shopping Experience with a list customized for your next visit to Amish Country Indiana.

1. JoJo's Pretzels

While the pretzels themselves might not last in the stocking, the cute wooden pretzel tokens are the perfect addition and make a wonderful excuse for a repeat visit to Shipshewana!

2. Yoder's Shipshewana Hardware

This is not your typical hardware store; although, they do have all the hardware items your heart desires. But they also have a large selection of gift items including everything from these old-fashioned toys to kitchen, bath, home décor, and so much more.

3. Victorian Candy Company

This cute candy store on the 2nd floor of Yoder’s Red Barn Shoppes, has an amazing assortment of fun and novelty candies like these freeze dried Skittles, Plus they feature their famous homemade Brickle Brackle and even homemade fudge with an assortment of flavors that are perfect for gift giving.

When you visit, you may even get a chance to see some Amish made fudge making in the process.

4. Yoder Popcorn

Yoder Popcorn has all kinds of popcorn and seasonings including items prepared and ready to snack on, and all ready to take back home or for you to prepare for that traditional Christmas Eve movie night!

5. Farmstead Inn & Conference Center

While you can purchase a gift card and send your loved one on a well-deserved getaway in Amish Country, you can also join them at the Farmstead Inn to get some quality time together. You’ll love to swim and relax in our restful Amish-inspired hotel that is the closest hotel to downtown sites and shops.

During Mid-November through December, you can also enjoy Shipshewana’s Lights of Joy (a 1.5-mile Christmas light Drive-Thru experience) before cozying up in your comfy room.

6. E & S Sales

This bulk foods store is packed with all kinds of unique candies that are perfect for kids of all ages’ stockings. You’ll find some classics like Cherry Slices or some fun extraordinary things like gummy eggs. “Only in Shipshewana” folks!

7. Glow Christian Bookstore

This perfect stop is always on my Stocking Stuffer list. I can’t resist picking up a new devotional for each member of my family to have Christmas morning to have for the start of the very upcoming new year! GLOW is a great place for this and so many more inspiring items for everyone on your Christmas shopping list.

8. Head Over Heels

In the basement of the Davis Mercantile is where you’ll find this fun and trendy shop that is great to find items for the adventurer in your life. They carry a number of unique brands and items for the stocking like these novelty socks in so many styles, jewelry, clothing and more!

9. Rebecca Haarer Arts & Antiques 

Photo Courtesy of VisitShipshewana.org

One of the highlights of this store are the World Market ornaments that I love to include each year as a stocking stuffer that builds a unique collection for each of my family to one day take on to their own homes to display on their Christmas Tree each year!

10. Shipshewana Cariloha

I promise, once you have tried these products, you’ll never go back to others. These bamboo towels, sheets and blankets are the ONLY ones I will ever use again!

Check Room Availability

11. B Honey & Candles

Nothing cuter than a honey bear peeking out of the top of a Christmas stocking to start off Christmas morning sweetly. They also feature a number of other honey products and flavors, plus gift items like their popular beeswax candles.

12. Simple Sounds

Some great little musical surprises can be found at what has become a family tradition for my kids. You’ll find all kinds of musical items from small instruments to a variety of gifts for the musician or just the music lover.

13. Red Wagon

Visit this great little toy shop that has a huge selection of great toys that really encourages the use of a child’s imagination. From games and puppets, to books and crafts, you’ll find fun and exciting items.

Plus, don’t forget to ride the beautifully designed 1906 Dentzel Carousel featuring hand-carved farm animals just outside this little shop on the 3rd Floor of the Davis Mercantile and enjoy this beautiful attraction for people of all ages!

14. Teaberry Wood Products

Teaberry has the most unique wooden creations I have ever seen. This one-of-a-kind shop has local craftmanship like no other around. You’ll find puzzles, inspirational words, baskets and so much more and all made by hand in Shipshewana.

15. Aunt Millie's Candy Store

Finding all kinds of unique candy confections including homemade goodies and chocolates, as well as, fun novelty candies from the past and some you’ve likely never heard of before. This is THE candy stop for you’re the special sweet tooth in your life.

16. Blue Gate Performing Arts Center

The Blue Gate has so many shows to choose from that would make amazing gifts for anyone in your family who already has everything they need. These one-of-a-kind experiences are a great fit for the stocking stuffer list!

And, this is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the many opportunities for purchasing special gifts for everyone on your Christmas list or just to enjoy some of the fun things to do in Indiana in our amazing little town, a hidden gem that captures the hearts of millions of travelers each year in Shipshewana Indiana.

Discover more things to do in Shipshewana by downloading our FREE Shipshewana Trip Planner.

Download Flea Market Trip Planner

Upcoming Events

There’s always something exciting happening at Shipshewana. Browse our upcoming events, and book a room today so that you don’t miss out on your favorite event!

Exclusive News & Deals

Sign up for our email list to stay up-to-date on the latest news and events at Shipshewana Trading Place!

Join Now

Vendor Selling Opportunities

Have items to sell? Check out all of the Shipshewana, Indiana selling opportunities for vendors, crafters, pickers, and more.

Learn More