10 Best Places to Get Cinnamon Rolls in Shipshewana, Indiana

Post Date: Aug 08, 2019

What would a trip to Amish Country be without indulging in the amazing baked goods. Shipshewana, IN is the 3rd Largest Amish Community in the United States just behind Holmes County, OH and Lancaster, PA.

Indiana’s Amish Country is home to some of the most delicious cinnamon rolls you have ever tasted. Join the elite club and complete the “Shipshewana Cinnamon Roll Stroll.” These are not your Mama’s canned cinnamon rolls! And, since a picture says 1,000 words...

Here are the top 10 amazing stops for the best cinnamon rolls in Shipshewana, Indiana:

10. Shipshewana Flea Market

345 S. Van Buren Street – Shipshewana, IN

If you're visiting the famous Shipshewana Auction & Flea Market and have a hankering for a delicious sweet treat, be sure to stop by the Backyard Barnyard Food Court for a cinnamon roll! Or, visit the vendor at flea market booth 516 (Bread Box Bakery) for more delicious cinnamon rolls, cookies, breads, and many baked goodies you can take back home or enjoy while shopping. 

9. Shipshewana Auction Restaurant

345 S. Van Buren Street – Shipshewana, IN

Located at the main entrance to the Auction & Flea Market, the Shipshewana Auction Restaurant is am Amish/Mennonite style restaurant with wonderful fresh homemade cinnamon rolls. They also serve a full breakfast menu with favorites like the Haystack Breakfast and the Farmer's Omelette.

8. Red Bud Gift Shop

457 S. Van Buren Street – Shipshewana, IN

Red Bud Gift Shop is a cozy cafe inside Yoder's Red Barn Shoppes that is famous for their loose leaf teas and gourmet coffees. But did you know they have amazing baked goods including cinnamon rolls? They are roughly the size of your head! 

7. E & S Sales

1265 N. SR 5 – Shipshewana, IN

Just look at that thick icing! Mouth watering yet?

E & S Sales is a popular bulk foods store with a wonderful bakery inside! Their cinnamon rolls are available with caramel, white or a combination of the two. The icing technique has been perfected to assure you get a taste with every single bite.

6. Bread Box Bakery

120 Morton Street – Shipshewana, IN

Bread Box Bakery & Cafe not only sets up a booth at the flea market, but they also have a downtown Shipshewana location! Carrying their famous cinnamon rolls, cookies, breads, baked goods and more, you can even stop in for a quick bite to eat.

Plus, did you know the bakery is actually the historical home of Shipshewana’s founder?

5. 5 & 20 Country Kitchen

7995 US 20 – Shipshewana, IN

The 5 & 20 Country Kitchen (named for it's location at the corner of State Rd 5 and US 20) is a popular stop in Shipshewana for good home-cooking and a great salad bar. But did you know they also have spectacular cinnamon rolls?

4. Naomi’s Candies

300 S. Van Buren Street – Shipshewana, IN

A hidden gem just inside Yoder’s Shopping Center, Naomi’s Candies carries a wide variety of sweet treats including these amazing Amish made cinnamon rolls.

Don’t forget to purchase a coffee while your there to help balance the delicious sweetness of these outstanding treats.

3. Blue Gate Bakery

195 N. Van Buren Street – Shipshewana, IN

A lot of people swear by the cinnamon rolls at the famous Blue Gate Bakery! These  rolls are packed with cinnamon and brown sugar, and topped with buttercream or caramel icing.

They also offer a pecan cinnamon roll that is topped with an abundance of pecans and caramel glaze.

Forgot to grab some while you were in Shipshewana? No worries! You can have them shipped right to your home even after your trip to Indiana’s Amish Country. 

2. Rise'n Roll Bakery

1065 N 1150 W – Middlebury, IN

You'll have to drive just a few miles west of Shipshewana to get there, but a trip to Rise'n Roll Bakery is well worth it!

This Amish style bakery specializes in preservative-free products including their cinnamon rolls. But if you want, they carry so much more including donuts, pies, breads, cheeses and their famous Cinnamon Carmel Donut.

And, you can stop in for lunch and even enjoy a picnic on the lawn using one of their provided quilts for guests.

1. Country Lane Bakery 

59162 CR 43 – Middlebury, IN

You’ll enjoy the short trip through the country to get these delicious cinnamon rolls on this Amish farm.

Country Lane Bakery offers all kinds of sweets including a selection of pies and breads. It sits just off the beaten path in nearby Middlebury, and it's easy to see why folks make the short drive to enjoy them. 

No matter how you “ice” them, these cinnamon rolls will have you coming back to Shipshewana over and over.

Want to discover more great reasons to love Shipshewana? Download our free Shipshewana Trip Planner to start planning your next visit to Indiana’s Amish Country.

Download Flea Market Trip Planner

Upcoming Events

There’s always something exciting happening at Shipshewana. Browse our upcoming events, and book a room today so that you don’t miss out on your favorite event!

Exclusive News & Deals

Sign up for our email list to stay up-to-date on the latest news and events at Shipshewana Trading Place!

Join Now

Vendor Selling Opportunities

Have items to sell? Check out all of the Shipshewana, Indiana selling opportunities for vendors, crafters, pickers, and more.

Learn More